Skip to content

One Nation Under Dog: Stories of Fear, Loss, and Betrayal

Last night, my husband and I began watching HBO’s documentary entitled, One Nation Under Dog: Stories of Fear, Loss, and BetrayalWe have not yet completed watching this documentary, but so far, it seems to be very well-done.  Below is a brief summary of this HBO documentary.

Americans have always had a love affair with canines, but lost amidst the pampering are unpleasant truths about dog ownership, care and commerce. ONE NATION UNDER DOG: STORIES OF FEAR, LOSS & BETRAYAL offers an eye-opening, three-part portrait ofAmerica’s complex relationship with dogs.

“Part One – Fear”: In the opening segment, Dr. Robert Taffet is taken to court by neighbors after several bite incidents involving his Rhodesian Ridgebacks in New Jersey.  Despite the severity of some of the attacks, he is deeply committed to his pets and wins his cases, including one in which a three-year-old girl’s ear was bitten off.  Eight months later, after the same dog bites a teenager, Dr. Taffet puts him down.

“Part Two – Loss”: The second section focuses on people coping with the loss of beloved pets.  This segment features a group of mourners sharing deep grief over recently deceased dogs in a pet-loss support group at the San Francisco SPCA; two women laying their dog to rest in the oldest pet cemetery in the U.S.; and a couple attempting to replace a beloved dog by cloning him. Also featured is Julie Adams, whose own love and loss of dogs has inspired her rescue work; with no shelters in her rural area, she’s taken it upon herself to care for and shelter more than 100 stray and abandoned dogs.

“Part Three – Betrayal”: The final section explores issues of overpopulation, shelters, rescuing, spaying and neutering. Approximately two million dogs are destroyed in animal shelters each year. This segment features three minutes of graphic footage shot by a film student showing dogs and puppies being euthanized.

Many people do not know that 25% of dogs in shelters are actually purebreds, and many pet store dogs come from mass breeding operations known as puppy mills.  For many dogs from mills and animal shelters, rescue is the only hope of survival.  This segment follows volunteers saving some 200 puppy mill dogs from these dire conditions, including rescuer-trainer John Gagnon, who rehabilitates aggressive, difficult-to-adopt dogs and works with an organization to find them good homes, and Shawn South-Aswad, who raises money to rescue dogs and place them with foster families.

ONE NATION UNDER DOG: STORIES OF FEAR, LOSS & BETRAYAL is produced by Ellen Goosenberg Kent; supervising editor, Geof Bartz, A.C.E.; co-producer, Larissa Bills; directed by Jenny Carchman, Ellen Goosenberg Kent, Amanda Micheli; editors, Geof Bartz, A.C.E., Joe Beshenkovsky, Seth Bomse, Traci Loth; producers, Larissa Bills, R.J. Cutler, Julie Goldman, Allyson Luchak, Amanda Micheli, Danielle Renfrew Behrens; inspired by the book “One Nation Under Dog,” by Michael Schaffer. For HBO: supervising producer, Lisa Heller; executive producer, Sheila Nevins.

For further reading, check out this article.


3 Comments Post a comment
  1. Katie – I met Michael Shaffer (the author of One Nation Under Dog) a few years ago. It sounds like a really interesting documentary. Wish I had HBO. Kim

    June 29, 2012
    • Thank you for your note, Kim. That is neat! Maybe it will be available at the library at some point so that you can view it?

      June 29, 2012
  2. maggi #

    It’s interesting. I’ve experienced the Fear, Loss and Betrayal over my years of dog ownership. Never would I have guessed that Benji could be the sweet and lovable fluff that he is today – based on his temperament when we first adopted him. When he bit my friend’s daughter, we struggled with whether or not we were the right family for him or whether ANY family would be right for him.

    Of course, you know about our losses. Each one is difficult. Each one different in their circumstances. None of them forgotten.

    Betrayal. Never had I felt this so much so than to learn about the breeding in the greyhound racing industry. It made me appreciate our greyhounds so much; knowing that they were the lucky ones who were able to get loving homes after their racing days. But more than half never get that chance. Many not living past age 2. And for what? Money. There is no accidental breeding with the NGA. Each dog is bred for profit. And if they don’t turn a profit from the start, many are put down without the chance to be adopted.

    I’m not sure I can watch the documentary, and you know I can watch study some pretty gruesome stuff. Maybe it is because I feel too emotionally attached and find that I cannot detach myself.

    July 2, 2012

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s